Home
Log in / Sign Up
    Private Messages   Rules   New User Guide   FAQ   Advertise   Contact Us  
Forum -> The Social Scene -> Entertainment
Shtisel - WITH spoilers :) including season 3
  Previous  1  2  3 44  45  46 75  76  77  Next



Post new topic   Reply to topic View latest: 24h 48h 72h

amother
  Ginger  


 

Post Wed, Jan 13 2021, 6:27 pm
amother [ Chocolate ] wrote:
There was a chuppah scene???? I missed it! That must have been when my screen went blank. I'll have to see if Sdarot is up yet!!!!

Now, here's what I was thinking about last night (wow how this thing takes over our thoughts!!!! Great that we can shmooze about it here while we wait anxiously for the next episode!!!)

Ruchami goes to another doctor who doesn't know her history. Is the guy an idiot? You see a young chareidi girl (remember she got married at 16 or something) with an IUD. Don't you think she probably has it for a medical reason?

You say her chart seems to be missing some things & you ask about allergies? & you don't ask why she has an IUD in the first place?

I understand it would not be a PC question, but seriously if you have any brains you ought to be thinking, no??

It‘s a movie after all. In real life in Israel there in no point whatsoever to drive to Rishon Letzion from Yerushalaim (or wherever she went) to a different doctor as a medical file of a person is digital and accessible everywhere. All her health difficulties will be seen everywhere.
Back to top

  shabbatiscoming  




 
 
    
 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 4:30 am
amother [ Ginger ] wrote:
It‘s a movie after all. In real life in Israel there in no point whatsoever to drive to Rishon Letzion from Yerushalaim (or wherever she went) to a different doctor as a medical file of a person is digital and accessible everywhere. All her health difficulties will be seen everywhere.
This is not true. This is only true if you go to a doctor in the same kupa, then its on the kupa system, but if one goes to a specialist or a private doctor, they will not see any of your information and will need to find it all out from the beginning.
Back to top

amother
  Azure  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 4:46 am
Racheli full name on the kesuba was rochel leah. She cant be Gabriella
Can someone fluent in hebrew confirm if avigail said its too late to cancel the surrogacy, you signed not to back out plus Gabriela got pregnant (I understood this ) or if she did cancel it (what ppl here are suggesting)?
Back to top

amother
  White  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 5:05 am
amother [ Azure ] wrote:
Racheli full name on the kesuba was rochel leah. She cant be Gabriella
Can someone fluent in hebrew confirm if avigail said its too late to cancel the surrogacy, you signed not to back out plus Gabriela got pregnant (I understood this ) or if she did cancel it (what ppl here are suggesting)?


It was left open ended. Avigail said that once she says it's final, it's final, and there is no going back. But she did leave Racheli the option of backing out, though she was taken aback. She said they won't be getting their initial first payment back in any case.
We don't know if Avigail called afterwards to say it's too late because the first attempt was a success.
Back to top

amother
  Ginger  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 5:09 am
amother [ Azure ] wrote:
Racheli full name on the kesuba was rochel leah. She cant be Gabriella
Can someone fluent in hebrew confirm if avigail said its too late to cancel the surrogacy, you signed not to back out plus Gabriela got pregnant (I understood this ) or if she did cancel it (what ppl here are suggesting)?

maybe she wanted to remain anonymous kind of and toold them to be called by other name...
No Avigail said if you cancel now, then that decision is final, there is no changing your mind again and you will not be getting the first instalment back because you signed it with this term. (Ruchami said to her husband that the pregnancy took but Avigail never said this)
How is it technically possible to cancel if they started already with treatment is beyond my mind though.
Back to top

amother
  Ginger  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 5:12 am
amother [ White ] wrote:
It was left open ended. Avigail said that once she says it's final, it's final, and there is no going back. But she did leave Racheli the option of backing out, though she was taken aback. She said they won't be getting their initial first payment back in any case.
We don't know if Avigail called afterwards to say it's too late because the first attempt was a success.
I think she cancelled anyway. Why would she take the spiral out?
Back to top

amother
  Mistyrose  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 5:28 am
I also missed the chuppah scene! It wasn't on the telegram link.
Where did y'all see it?
Back to top

amother
Red  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 6:50 am
Is it possible that Racheli was the surrogate and was using a false name (Gabriella) because they said they wanted the process to be anonymous. Then when they canceled Racheli was at a crossroads (hence lying on the couch rubbing her stomach). Akiva came with his problem and she realized she had a way out. If she married akiva even for a couple of days she could say the baby is his and keep it.
Back to top

  Moonlight  




 
 
    
 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 7:46 am
amother [ Red ] wrote:
Is it possible that Racheli was the surrogate and was using a false name (Gabriella) because they said they wanted the process to be anonymous. Then when they canceled Racheli was at a crossroads (hence lying on the couch rubbing her stomach). Akiva came with his problem and she realized she had a way out. If she married akiva even for a couple of days she could say the baby is his and keep it.

Wow haven't thought of this.
Back to top

amother
  Babypink  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 9:21 am
amother [ Red ] wrote:
Is it possible that Racheli was the surrogate and was using a false name (Gabriella) because they said they wanted the process to be anonymous. Then when they canceled Racheli was at a crossroads (hence lying on the couch rubbing her stomach). Akiva came with his problem and she realized she had a way out. If she married akiva even for a couple of days she could say the baby is his and keep it.


Wow ! This makes total sense!

I was thinking of a few ways this could go..
A. The surrogacy was stopped, though Chanina doesn't know this. Meanwhile Ruchami gets pregnant but Chanina thinks she is carrying pillows. At the end she will die in childbirth (or not). He will end up with s child but no wife.
B. The surrogacy was successful and a baby is on the way. Ruchami's ruse is discovered and her pregnancy is terminated before she could get too far. They somehow find out that the surrogacy was successful but they have to fight for their baby. Avigail will say it's too late, you gave it up. It will go to court.
C. Ruchami will get pregnant and miraculously give birth. She will be on death's door but will come through in the end. Meanwhile the surrogate mom will give birth as well. Chanina will be left with a huge conflict whether or not to claim the "bdieved" baby. Especially since the baby will be almost the same age as the one ruchami gives birth to.

Question: how can Avigail allow Ruchami to terminate the agreement over the phone? Very unprofessional. Wouldn't Ruchami and Chanina have to sign documents? This isn't a game...
Back to top

amother
  Babypink  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 9:26 am
amother [ Mistyrose ] wrote:
I also missed the chuppah scene! It wasn't on the telegram link.
Where did y'all see it?


Sdarot
Back to top

amother
  Ginger  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 9:31 am
amother [ Babypink ] wrote:
Wow ! This makes total sense!

I was thinking of a few ways this could go..
A. The surrogacy was stopped, though Chanina doesn't know this. Meanwhile Ruchami gets pregnant but Chanina thinks she is carrying pillows. At the end she will die in childbirth (or not). He will end up with s child but no wife.
B. The surrogacy was successful and a baby is on the way. Ruchami's ruse is discovered and her pregnancy is terminated before she could get too far. They somehow find out that the surrogacy was successful but they have to fight for their baby. Avigail will say it's too late, you gave it up. It will go to court.
C. Ruchami will get pregnant and miraculously give birth. She will be on death's door but will come through in the end. Meanwhile the surrogate mom will give birth as well. Chanina will be left with a huge conflict whether or not to claim the "bdieved" baby. Especially since the baby will be almost the same age as the one ruchami gives birth to.

Question: how can Avigail allow Ruchami to terminate the agreement over the phone? Very unprofessional. Wouldn't Ruchami and Chanina have to sign documents? This isn't a game...

I vote for C!
Back to top

amother
  Cerulean  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 10:30 am
amother [ Babypink ] wrote:
Wow ! This makes total sense!

I was thinking of a few ways this could go..
A. The surrogacy was stopped, though Chanina doesn't know this. Meanwhile Ruchami gets pregnant but Chanina thinks she is carrying pillows. At the end she will die in childbirth (or not). He will end up with s child but no wife.
B. The surrogacy was successful and a baby is on the way. Ruchami's ruse is discovered and her pregnancy is terminated before she could get too far. They somehow find out that the surrogacy was successful but they have to fight for their baby. Avigail will say it's too late, you gave it up. It will go to court.
C. Ruchami will get pregnant and miraculously give birth. She will be on death's door but will come through in the end. Meanwhile the surrogate mom will give birth as well. Chanina will be left with a huge conflict whether or not to claim the "bdieved" baby. Especially since the baby will be almost the same age as the one ruchami gives birth to.

Question: how can Avigail allow Ruchami to terminate the agreement over the phone? Very unprofessional. Wouldn't Ruchami and Chanina have to sign documents? This isn't a game...


Very unprofessional. I thought so too. But not as unrealistic as some of the other goings on.

I want to vote C too like Ginger did.
Not because I think it's likely to happen, but because I think it's the most creative and interesting and can give us some great fraught with emotion scenes.
I think A is the most likely, including the dying in childbirth. Ruchami and Chanina are both really good at doing the grief stricken face. I think Ruchami will do a great tragic face when Chanina discovers her betrayal and Chanina will do the same when he's holding his motherless newborn baby, or maybe as he looks at a sad, bewildered but still in control Gitty holding her orphaned grandchild.

ETA - No way Rachelli is the surrogate. I owe you all virtual ice cream cones if I'm wrong!
Back to top

amother
  Ginger  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 10:32 am
amother [ Cerulean ] wrote:
Very unprofessional. I thought so too. But not as unrealistic as some of the other goings on.

I want to vote C too like Ginger did.
Not because I think it's likely to happen, but because I think it's the most creative and interesting and can give us some great fraught with emotion scenes.
I think A is the most likely, including the dying in childbirth. Ruchami and Chanina are both really good at doing the grief stricken face. I think Ruchami will do a great tragic face when Chanina discovers her betrayal and Chanina will do the same when he's holding his motherless newborn baby, or maybe as he looks at a sad, bewildered but still in control Gitty holding her orphaned grandchild.

you are right but I hope the producers, also already quite repetative, will not „kill“ another mother of a baby, enough is enough
Back to top

amother
  Sapphire  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 10:46 am
amother [ Cerulean ] wrote:
Very unprofessional. I thought so too. But not as unrealistic as some of the other goings on.

I want to vote C too like Ginger did.
Not because I think it's likely to happen, but because I think it's the most creative and interesting and can give us some great fraught with emotion scenes.
I think A is the most likely, including the dying in childbirth. Ruchami and Chanina are both really good at doing the grief stricken face. I think Ruchami will do a great tragic face when Chanina discovers her betrayal and Chanina will do the same when he's holding his motherless newborn baby, or maybe as he looks at a sad, bewildered but still in control Gitty holding her orphaned grandchild.

ETA - No way Rachelli is the surrogate. I owe you all virtual ice cream cones if I'm wrong!


Agreed!
Back to top

amother
  Wine


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 11:00 am
amother [ Babypink ] wrote:
Wow ! This makes total sense!

I was thinking of a few ways this could go..
A. The surrogacy was stopped, though Chanina doesn't know this. Meanwhile Ruchami gets pregnant but Chanina thinks she is carrying pillows. At the end she will die in childbirth (or not). He will end up with s child but no wife.
B. The surrogacy was successful and a baby is on the way. Ruchami's ruse is discovered and her pregnancy is terminated before she could get too far. They somehow find out that the surrogacy was successful but they have to fight for their baby. Avigail will say it's too late, you gave it up. It will go to court.
C. Ruchami will get pregnant and miraculously give birth. She will be on death's door but will come through in the end. Meanwhile the surrogate mom will give birth as well. Chanina will be left with a huge conflict whether or not to claim the "bdieved" baby. Especially since the baby will be almost the same age as the one ruchami gives birth to.

Question: how can Avigail allow Ruchami to terminate the agreement over the phone? Very unprofessional. Wouldn't Ruchami and Chanina have to sign documents? This isn't a game...




Based on the seasons trailer A. doesnt seem likely as Chanina is seen telling a pregnant looking Ruchami its your life to which she responds I have no life without this which indicates that he found out. Dont see how its possible for him not to.
Back to top

amother
  Tan  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 11:04 am
Good points- like the foreshadowing that ruchami and Chanina declined to meet the surrogate- if so can this get any more twisted - not sure I want to know the answer to that
Guess if the producers think everyone can lie so much then Rachelli could too R”L
And so it goes the biases of some (producers etc) on the chareidim as lying hypocrites Chas v shalom
Back to top

amother
  Babypink  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 11:12 am
amother [ Wine ] wrote:
Based on the seasons trailer A. doesnt seem likely as Chanina is seen telling a pregnant looking Ruchami its your life to which she responds I have no life without this which indicates that he found out. Dont see how its possible for him not to.


Actually, option A is that Ruchami gets pregnant. So according to the season trailer, it is likely to be A. She gets pregnant and he discovers it at some point. Ruchami either goes ahead with the birth or the birth is terminated. Ruchami either dies or doesn't die.
If she dies, Chanina is left with a little girl named Ruchami.
If Ruchami doesnt die, she will possibly end up with two kids, the one she gave birth to, and the surragate baby, which ends up being a month or two older. How strange is that? And they have to fight for the baby. Ruchami will want that baby also and Chanina will say one is enough. (Why be greedy?)
Or maybe she dies and Chanina is left alone with two kids? (He is not likely to get custody of the surrogate child since Ruchami gave up rights. )
Also, is it likely that they will have to abort the baby to save Ruchamis life? Ruchami would never agree to that.
I need a flowchart over here to map out all the possibilities. LOL
Back to top

amother
  Babypink  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 11:17 am
amother [ Ginger ] wrote:
you are right but I hope the producers, also already quite repetative, will not „kill“ another mother of a baby, enough is enough

Good point! Too much death.
Since season one we saw the death of:
Shulem's wife
Bubbie Malka shtisel
Rebbetzin Erblich
The rebbe in the cheder (forget his name)
The shadchan
Libby
Libbi's mother
Sucher
Two husbands of Elisheva
Back to top

amother
  Babypink  


 

Post Thu, Jan 14 2021, 11:22 am
amother [ Cerulean ] wrote:
Very unprofessional. I thought so too. But not as unrealistic as some of the other goings on.

ETA - No way Rachelli is the surrogate. I owe you all virtual ice cream cones if I'm wrong!


Why do you think Rachelli can't be the surrogate?
Back to top
Page 45 of 77   Previous  1  2  3 44  45  46 75  76  77  Next Recent Topics




Post new topic   Reply to topic    Forum -> The Social Scene -> Entertainment

Related Topics Replies Last Post
Winter hats for girls this season
by amother
2 Thu, Oct 31 2024, 11:48 pm View last post
Inexpensive wedding options in or near NYC including boros
by amother
0 Mon, Oct 21 2024, 10:21 pm View last post
Is watermelon still in season (nyc)
by amother
2 Sun, Oct 06 2024, 2:07 pm View last post
Missing some clothing for yt/ new season
by amother
4 Sun, Sep 29 2024, 7:33 pm View last post
Please post your SHEIN links for this season!
by amother
10 Mon, Sep 23 2024, 10:45 pm View last post