Magazine Sukkos 2024 fiction supplements

amother

Navy

Mon, Oct 28 2024, 9:16 am

I only bought Mispacha, but I was very disappointed that none of their stories had even a passing reference to the war. I get that they are international, but the war in Israel affects all of us. Maybe they didn't want to be depressing, and a story fully based around the war might not have been suitable, but a passing reference to the difficulties of flying, or the potential for sirens would not have been out of place.

During covid there was stories that dealt with the realities of life in lockdown, and others that just mentioned it as a background consideration. They didn't devote the entire supplement to it, and that was fine, but they didn't ignore it either. Now they're suddenly ignoring the reality of life for all their Israeli readers, and many in other countries who have been affected by it.

farm

Mon, Oct 28 2024, 9:34 am

amother Navy wrote:

The main magazine part II was almost 50% war with a whole bunch of different angles on the top. Extremely well done and way more appropriate than a fictional story ‘using’ it as part of the plot!

amother

NeonOrange

Mon, Oct 28 2024, 11:18 am

amother Navy wrote:

People who experience a loss or go through a tragedy might not want to see it in a fictional piece. Mishpacha had a lot of articles every week in the last year about the war, including a lot in the Rosh Hashana and Succos editions. These were all factual articles about real events quoting real people.
I know someone who survived the Holocaust who hated Holocaust fiction. For many of us it’s how we learned about what happened but that was exactly her point. In fictional pieces there are always inaccuracies, sometimes because of the ignorance of the author and sometimes because of the need to develop the plot or the characters. People living through the actual horrible events can find that hurtful. Maybe in a few years we’ll be ready for October 7 fiction and maybe never, but this year was for sure not the time.

dena613

Sun, Nov 03 2024, 8:14 am

farm wrote:

The main magazine part II was almost 50% war with a whole bunch of different angles on the top. Extremely well done and way more appropriate than a fictional story ‘using’ it as part of the plot!

Yes, main magazine had SO many features about the war!!
I don't think you need to make it fictional.
I think it would even be a bit sacrilegious.

amother

Hydrangea

Today at 8:10 am

I know it's late in the game, but I just finished reading the Calligraphy last night. I was amazed at how the last story about the Hatzalah wife could have been me except I'm not a perfectionist. I know the feeling of wanting dh home and he runs out on yet another call.

And then dh came home from the store with the Shabbos party nosh he bought for dd, the Shabbos mommy. And it was winkie lollipops, which dd hates! (The dh in the story bought lollipops which the mother thought was too boring.) I am sending her with the lollies and a package of cookies that she likes.

allthingsblue

Today at 8:34 am

amother Navy wrote:

Since October 7 every single Mishpacha issue whether in main mag or family first has had an article about the war

Fiction about the war would be insulting

These are real people’s lives
The hostages are still hostages, soldiers are still injured, families are still displaced

Let the focus be on their real stores not fiction