New engagement ring

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:14 pm Post subject: new engagement ring

so im married 3 years, and my engagment ring has 4 small diamonds on the side of the diamond. one had fallen out and got lost and we recently got it replaced at the same store it was purchased at. well today I noticed one missing again Evil or Very Mad

the diamonds are kind of suspended in air with not much holding on to them.. so the store said that either I can get a brand new one of the same ring, or I can choose a totaly new setting in that price range..

so, what do you think?

should I get the same one sinc its the one I got when we got married, hence its more special, or should I get a differnet one which in the long run will make me happier?
_________________
Dovid Shlomo- 8/31/03
Yosef Binyamin-5/21/05
Tiferes Esther- 7/17/07
Yonason Matisyahu- 6/3/09
Adara Raizel- 3/3/11
k'h

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:16 pm Post subject: re: new engagement ring

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:20 pm Post subject: re: new engagement ring

Maybe just get it repaired and put it aside. Alot of people just keep their engagement rings with out wearing them, especially when they are busy with kids all the time.

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:21 pm Post subject: re: new engagement ring

thats not an option, I want to wear it all the time, whats the point of putting away a really expensive diamond

Platinum Member Joined: May 16 2005 Posts: 6262

it sounds to me like you want a new one, so I think you should do that. the ring is gonna be a new one anyway so it doesnt matter if its the same style or not.

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:23 pm Post subject: re: new engagement ring

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:24 pm Post subject: Re: re: new engagement ring

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:26 pm Post subject: re: new engagement ring

lol, more the reason to wear it close to you at all times...

I understand your thinking, its just that I wear it all the time and im proud of it and the meaning behind it, not thta your not.. and I want to like the way it looks, right now I hate looking down and seeing a missing diamond....

as they say, a diamond is a girls best friend

Platinum Member Joined: May 16 2005 Posts: 6262

if you like it the way it is then get a new one but the same ring again.

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:38 pm Post subject: re: new engagement ring

yeah but the likelihood of this same thing happenig again is very high, since its a bad design..

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:38 pm Post subject: re: new engagement ring

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:41 pm Post subject: re: new engagement ring

I kind of want a new one an kind of dont... if you had the option to get something differnt/nicer would you?

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 10:43 pm Post subject: re: new engagement ring

No I wouldn't, because the sentiment to me would be in the original one.
That's why I would get it repaired and put it somewhere safe. Just my opinion though.

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 11:30 pm Post subject:

I have a similar problem. My ring has begets (little diamonds) on the band. I'm married 2 1/2 years and so far 1 has cracked and 1 was missing. I think it must be a poor quality setting. If it happens again, I will probably just switch bands. If it's the setting that is no good, I suggest trying a new one. It's still the same diamond, and the real diamond is the person who gave it to you!!
_________________
"G-d's gifts to you are your talents...How you use them is your gift to G-d."

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 11:34 pm Post subject: re: new engagement ring

yeah im kind of agreeing with you.. although my husband just said, yu can only worry too much and something is alwys gona come up.. but I just dont like the idea of mssing diamondsn o matter how small they are.. so maybe ill just look at the other ones and then make my decisin.. my ring is really a beatiuful one.. the diamond in the middle is set high and then 4 small diamonds on the side, white gold... I just odnt know

Posted: Sat, Nov 26 2005, 11:38 pm Post subject:

go and see what the the other options are and then decide.
ask husband what he thinks?
_________________
Rivky- 5 yrs , Shmuly-4 yrs, Tzemach 2 yrs, Mirel- newborn

Gold Member Joined: Jan 18 2005 Posts: 1546

I really like my setting its pretty plain but if I had ur trouble and its not my favorite setting htan I wud c wat kind of setting I cud get that I like more for the same price
enjoy watever u do Smile

Platinum Member Joined: Jan 17 2005 Posts: 5505

I wish I could claim this as my own suggestion but I know someone who already did it....have it made into a necklace, then u can wear it the whole time WITHOUT the risk of damaging it...

Platinum Member Joined: May 16 2005 Posts: 6262

I just got a new setting and I love it. I didnt like my old one. this is rellay up to you. would u like to have it and never wear it?? or have one that you like more that doesnt break! ?

Moderator Joined: Nov 20 2005 Posts: 4868

I would do as Brachad says, let your dh give you the new setting. The diamonds are the same and the "diamond" is the same.

If you're doing it already, get something really nice!!
Smile