Judy or Isabel pony shaitel?

Posted: Sun, May 11 2008, 4:42 pm Post subject: Judy or Isabel pony shaitel?

What is the difference between these two pony shaitels? They are the same price but which one has better quality hair, I know both are processed hair but which is still better? Also which one has a more natural look in the back that you can't tell you are wearing a shaitel? Does anyone have any of these pony shaitels that they can comment on it for me? Thanks.

Executive Member Joined: Aug 05 2007 Posts: 342

I love my Judy pony, looks and feels really great, I get lots of compliments on it, I have it a year now, and I'm gonna have to dye it for the summer again, cuz its getting lighter.
_________________
"When you aim for perfection, you discover it's a moving target."

Posted: Sun, May 11 2008, 6:43 pm Post subject: re: Judy or Isabel pony shaitel?

Where did you buy the Judy and how much was it? Also in the back do you see the difference between the shaitel and your hair?

Gold Member Joined: Apr 25 2007 Posts: 1231

I have the isabel and am very happy. I get lots of compliments. I even wear it down sometimes, even though the hair is very processed, it seems ok and doesn't look bad at all. I get compliments on it when I wear it down too! Smile

I was told when buying a ponytail sheital to just make sure that the hair doesn't feel dry...it should feel soft and silky (obviously not as silky as a not so processed more expensive reg sheital...but still soft and not dried out looking/feeling) so whichever one you end up going with I tihnk you should make sure of that...

Silver Member Joined: Jan 29 2008 Posts: 612

I was just wondering why people buy a specific wig for ponies. why cant you take an existing wig and put it in a pony like you would do with your natural hair?

Posted: Sun, May 11 2008, 9:30 pm Post subject: re: Judy or Isabel pony shaitel?

People buy pony shaitels because they are cheap and so you don't care if you ruin it or oxidy it. It is only for a pony and after the summer you don't mind throwing it out.

Senior Member Joined: Feb 14 2008 Posts: 200

I have the Judy Ponytail and wear it down in layers.
I get amillion compliments people always think it is a much more expensive sheitel.

Posted: Mon, May 12 2008, 1:07 pm Post subject: re: Judy or Isabel pony shaitel?

Where do you buy a Judy and how much are they?

Executive Member Joined: Aug 05 2007 Posts: 342

you can buy the judy at her salon, or at a sheital macher that sells it
I think it goes for about 800 including the cut.

Senior Member Joined: Feb 14 2008 Posts: 200

I bought mine at a sheitel sale from a girl in Brooklyn I paid 600 and 100 for the cut by a girl named Gitel Rosenzwieg

Executive Member Joined: Jun 02 2008 Posts: 329

With Judys and Isabels, you get what you pay for. Not worth it in my opinion.

Silver Member Joined: Dec 18 2006 Posts: 694 Location: NY

Senior Member Joined: Sep 11 2006 Posts: 194

Someone just told my sister about a Judy pony sheitel, she wants to know if anyone has it and is happy with it. I saw a few people who posted in favor of it, but I'm just wondering if anyone else has gotten one since. Also, does anyone know how it compares quality-wise to Milano?

Executive Member Joined: Aug 19 2006 Posts: 451